Wednesday, 1 January 2025

An Interfaith Marriage in 1885

Moses Williamson and Caroline Munro were married by Nathaniel Kinsman on 16 December 1885 according to the rights of the Free Church of England in Moor Street, Fitzroy, Victoria, Australia.[i]

Christian Israelite Church

Moseswas born on 17 September 1863, in St Kilda[ii] and named(baptised) in October 1863 into the Christian Israelite Church, Fitzroy[iii]

The Christian Israelite Church was established in England in the 19th century by John Wroe. It emerged as a millenarian sect within the broader Christian tradition.

1.       Combination of Christian and Old Testament Practices:

  • The church emphasizes the Old Testament laws, such as observing dietary restrictions and celebrating certain feasts (similar to Jewish customs).
  • At the same time, it retains core Christian beliefs, including the acceptance of Jesus Christ as the Messiah and a focus on New Testament teachings.

2.       Focus on Prophecy: The church places significant importance on apocalyptic and messianic prophecies, with Wroe positioning himself as a prophet. This focus aligns with the Christian expectation of the Second Coming and some elements of Jewish messianic hopes.

The Church blends aspects of Jewish tradition (e.g., observance of Mosaic laws) with Christian theology, forming a unique and distinct religious framework. It is rooted in the belief that true Christians must adhere to God's laws as given to the Israelites while also recognizing Jesus as the fulfillment of those laws.

Melbourne Society of Spiritual Research

Caroline Munro was born on 09 December 1864 and baptised on 25 December 1864 in the Scotch Church, in Mhow, India.[iv] After coming to Australia Caroline’s mother, Isabella Jennings, became “an original member of the Melbourne Society of Spiritual Research.”[v]

Melbourne Society of Spiritual Research is centred on spiritualism, which seeks to explore and understand the nature of the spirit world. It is less about adhering to dogmatic religious structures and more about metaphysical inquiry, communication with spirits, and investigating paranormal phenomena. It aligns with 19th-century spiritualist movements that valued mediumship, séances, and a belief in life after death. Practices involve séances, spirit communication, and exploring paranormal phenomena. There is no formal adherence to laws or sacraments; instead, the focus is on personal spiritual growth and empirical exploration of the unseen world.

This indicates that Caroline was raised in an environment where spiritualism—an exploration of the afterlife and metaphysical phenomena—was prominent

Summary of Differences

Aspect

Christian Israelite Church

Melbourne Society of Spiritual Research

Foundation

Christianity with Old Testament emphasis

Spiritualism and metaphysical inquiry

View of Jesus

Central as Messiah

Not emphasized

Scripture

Bible as authoritative

Open to diverse spiritual and metaphysical texts

Afterlife

Heaven and hell through salvation in Christ

Ongoing spiritual communication after death

Practices

Biblical laws, sacraments, prophecy

Séances, mediumship, spirit communication

Mission

Salvation and moral living

Exploration of spiritual and paranormal realms

 

While the Christian Israelite Church and the Melbourne Society of Spiritual Research were fundamentally different in theology and practice, they shared common ground in rejecting mainstream religious norms, emphasizing personal spiritual experiences, engaging with the supernatural, and fostering communities for seekers of alternative truths.

Free Church of England

Moses Williamson and Caroline Munro were married by Nathaniel Kinsman according to the rights of the Free Church of England in Moor Street, Fitzroy, Victoria, Australia.[vi]

The Rev Nathaniel Kinsman resided in Moore St, Fitzroy and was registered to conduct marriages.[vii] An interesting man, he originally a served in the St Mark’s Church, Church of England in Fitzroy but did not complete his ordination, instead he left the established church and “founded a church of his own and … carried on simultaneously the businesses of parson and second hand salesman.”[viii] Although not a minister in the normal sense he was the head of a Church known by its members as the "Victorian Free Church" but which he insisted on calling it by its more formal name "Victorian Free Church of England”.[ix]

“Rev. Mr Kinsman made no attempt to ape ecclesiastical dignities. … Even when called upon to exercise the matrimonial functions of his alternative profession, he did not trouble to make any alteration in his clothing. But, in fact, it was hardly worthwhile for such a mere matter of everyday business. The auctioneer walked out of his shop into his private parlor, and by the simple act of crossing the mat was transformed into the priest. The couples, … seated themselves on the well worn sofa, sanctified by so many thousands of similar union, and the whole thing was over in a very few minutes. The parson went back to his shop, and the happy couple departed to realise the meaning of "Till death us do part."[x]

The choice to marry under Rev. Nathaniel Kinsman of the Free Church of England, known for accommodating couples from diverse backgrounds without unnecessary questions, may reflect their desire to avoid religious conflict, given their markedly different religious backgrounds.

Freemasonry

Moses became a Freemason in 1888 three years after getting married.[xi] Freemasonry's emphasis on tolerance, inclusivity, and respect for diverse religious perspectives likely fostered an open-minded approach to spiritual and cultural differences.[xii]

Freemasonry is not tied to a specific religion[xiii] and requires only a belief in a Supreme Being. This non-sectarian approach encourages its members to respect and engage with individuals from varied religious backgrounds. This would have made it easier for Moses to respect Caroline’s family's spiritual heritage, even if it differed from his own upbringing in the Christian Israelite Church.

  Useful links for background

WikiTree profile for Moses Williamson (1863 - 1933) & Caroline (Munro) Williamson (1864 - 1968)

Blogpost Meta Data

The URL for this post is:  https://ancestralresearchjournal.blogspot.com/2025/01/an-interfaith-marriage-in-1885.html Originally published on 1 January 2025

Please comment on this post on the website by clicking the URL above and then the "Comments" link at the bottom of each post. Share it on Twitter/X, Facebook, or Pinterest using the icons below. Or contact me by email via the Contact Form on the Blog.


[i] Registry of Birth, Death and Marriages, Victoria, Australia, Marriage Certificate Moses Williamson & Caroline Munro 7312/1885

[ii] Birth Certificate of Moses Williamson child of John Williamson(draper) & Louisa WALKER, residing in St Kilda, Victoria, born 17 September 1863 in St Kilda, Victoria, Australia. Victoria State Government, Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages Victoria, Australia, Registration number 23188 / 1863.

[iii] Email correspondence, Lynne Gary (Member of Christian Israelite Church) to Sandra Williamson, email, Subject line: “John Williamson family” 19 March 2022, Original in author’s possession.

[iv] Baptism of Caroline Munro born 09 Dec 1864  and baptised 25 Dec 1864, daughter of Andrew (Qr Master Serjeant 21st Brigade R.A) & Isabella Munro, residing in Mhow, Parish register Mhow, Scotch Church, last entry on page 443, for 1864; citing Findmypast, Parish register from the Presidency of Bengal (database with images); British India Office Births & Baptisms N-1-110 folio 443

[v] 1937 'Will Spend Christmas Looking Back Over Century', The Argus (Melbourne, Vic. : 1848 - 1957), 24 December, p. 1. , viewed 23 Dec 2024, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article11135449

[vi] Registry of Birth, Death and Marriages, Victoria, Australia, Marriage Certificate Moses Williamson & Caroline Munro 7312/1885

[vii] 1908 'MARRIAGE ACTS AMENDMENT.', The Argus (Melbourne, Vic. : 1848 - 1957), 29 July, p. 6. , viewed 29 Dec 2024, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article10176372

[viii] 1898 'OUR ILLUSTRATIONS.', Weekly Times (Melbourne, Vic. : 1869 - 1954), 5 March, p. 13. , viewed 29 Dec 2024, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article221138558

[ix] 1898 'OUR ILLUSTRATIONS.', Weekly Times (Melbourne, Vic. : 1869 - 1954), 5 March, p. 13. , viewed 29 Dec 2024, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article221138558

[x] 1898 'OUR ILLUSTRATIONS.', Weekly Times (Melbourne, Vic. : 1869 - 1954), 5 March, p. 13. , viewed 29 Dec 2024, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article221138558

[xi] Library and Museum of Freemasonry; London, England; Membership entry of Moses Williamson aged 25, tailor member of the Victoria Lodge, Hawthorn Victoria, initiated 13 November 1888mFreemasonry Membership Registers; Description: Membership Registers: Colonial and Foreign I 1788-1919 to Colonial and Foreign J 1923-2037; Reel Number: 27, Lodge Number 2009, Folio Number 251

[xii] "Freemasonry: A Journey Through Ritual and Symbol" by Walter L. Wilmshurst, publisher Thames and Hudson, 1991

[xiii] Royal Craftsman, N.J. ‘Freemasonry and Ts Relation to Religion’. The Freemason’s Chronicle XXVL, no. 654 (23 July 1887): page1